| Rev. John Mackenna | 1869-1877 |
| Rev. Richard Foley | 1877-1891 |
| Rev. James Crowley | 1891-1894 |
| Rev. Myles O'Reilly | 1894-1899 |
| Rev. James Lynch | 1899-1901 |
| Rev. Peter Matthews | 1901-1906 |
| Rev. Edward Holley | 1906-1912 |
| Rev. Francis J. Uleau | 1912-1915 |
| Rev. Martin O'Malley | 1915-1916 |
| Rev. Edward F. Mcgrath | 1916-1924 |
| Rev. George Sherman | 1924-1929 |
| Rev. Augustine Rath | 1929-1931 |
| Rev. Joseph A. Reilly | 1931-1937 |
| Rev. Raymond Costello | 1937-1943 |
| Rev. Patrick McLaughlin | 1943-1956 |
| Rev. Charles T. Carow | 1956-1957 |
| Rev. Mortimer J. Gleason | 1957-1963 |
| Rev. John F. Mahoney | 1963-1966 |
| Rev. John T. Fisher | 1966-1966 |
| Rev. Donald G. Crynes | 1966-1969 |
| Rev. Aloysius J. D'Lag | 1969-1973 |
| Msgr. William H. Flaherty | 1973-1985 |
| Rev. Martin J. Osborne | 1985-1995 |
| Rev. George J. Michell | 1995-2010 |
| Rev. Peter J. Garry | 2010-2016 |
